Dr. Sally Winston on Self-Talk

Self-Talk Can Be Helpful or Unhelpful When It Comes to Uncertainty by Dr. Sally Winston

“ Now that you know more about therapeutic reassurance, it is easy to see that some self-talk can be productive reassurance and some can be unproductive. Knowing the difference is important, because hammering away at unproductive reassurance, quietly and desperately, in an attempt to feel more certain is a sure way to solidify the reassurance trap. Here are some examples of productive self-talk: 

  • I can put one foot in front of the other even while I feel scared. 
  • I can do this even though I’m not absolutely certain. 
  • It is okay to be anxious and also do this. 
  • I can go on without asking for reassurance, even though I would like some more. 
  • I am having my usual doubts right now. This is not a message or a signal. It is automatic. 
  • This is my best guess, and I’m going to take it, because I’m getting stuck. 

You’ll note that all these examples are about dealing with the uncertainty one feels by just letting the uncertainty be there. They’re not about seeking comfort from the anxiety; rather, they’re about dealing with the anxiety while proceeding forward. 
Here are some examples of unproductive self-talk. Notice that each statement is an attempt to eliminate uncertainty: 

  • Everything will be okay. 
  • I will check the weather to make sure my flight is safe. 
  • I won’t make any mistakes. 
  • God would never give me cancer or take my children. 
  • I can always leave if I need to. 
  • I am a fine person who would never do something like that. 
  • I must banish all doubts. 
  • Stop thinking that negative thing; think this positive thing. 

Helpful Fact: Self-talk can be helpful or unhelpful, depending on whether it consists of productive or unproductive reassurance.
Seif, Martin N.; Winston, Sally M.. Needing to Know for Sure (pp. 24-25). New Harbinger Publications. Kindle Edition.